Sell coins in Huntington, Long Island

A pile of old coins is shown in this photo

Sell coins on Long Island to a local coin dealer

A coin can be worth its metal, its rarity, or both, and a fair offer has to look at both. Gold Coast Jewelry & Pawn is a coin dealer and precious metal buyer in Huntington, so you can sell coins on Long Island face to face, with the coin in front of you while we explain what drives its price.

Bring one coin or a whole collection to 1786 E Jericho Turnpike, or call 631-735-6880 first if you want to talk it through.

Coins we buy in Huntington

Gold coins

Bullion coins such as American Gold Eagles, Buffalos, Maple Leafs and Krugerrands, plus older U.S. gold such as Liberty and Saint-Gaudens double eagles. Bullion coins are priced mostly on their gold weight. Older U.S. gold can be worth more than its metal when the date and condition are scarce.

Silver coins

U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver. Kennedy half dollars from 1965 to 1970 are 40% silver. Morgan and Peace dollars, Silver Eagles and silver rounds are all welcome too. If you are not sure what you have, a quick sort by date usually tells you. For silver jewelry, flatware and bars, see our sell silver page.

Collectible and inherited collections

Proof sets, mint sets, rolls, albums and estate collections. Inherited collections are often a mix of bullion, common coins and a few pieces worth far more than their metal. Keep them together and unsorted until they are looked at, so nothing valuable is sold for melt.

How a coin offer is worked out

Every offer starts from two numbers, and we show you both.

  • Melt value: the weight of the gold or silver in the coin times the day’s market price. Metal prices move every day, so an offer reflects that day’s price.
  • Collector value: the date, mint mark, rarity and condition. A common coin is worth about its melt value. A scarce date in good condition can be worth many times more.

One tip before you come in: do not clean your coins. Polishing or scrubbing leaves fine scratches, and collectors pay less for a cleaned coin than for the same coin left as it is.

Need cash but want to keep your coins?

If you would rather not sell, your coins can be collateral for a pawn loan with no credit check. You get cash now and your coins back when the loan is repaid. See how our pawn loans on Long Island work.

Questions about selling coins on Long Island

Where can I sell coins near me on Long Island?

At Gold Coast Jewelry & Pawn, 1786 E Jericho Turnpike in Huntington. We are open Monday to Saturday from 10 am (to 6 pm on Wednesday, 5 pm the other days) and Sunday 11 am to 4 pm.

How do I know if my coins are worth more than their metal?

Look at the date, the mint mark and the condition. Common dates trade near melt value. Scarce dates, low mintages and coins in strong condition carry a collector premium. Bring the coin in and we will check both values with you.

Which U.S. coins contain silver?

Dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 or earlier are 90% silver. Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970 are 40% silver. Most coins minted after that contain no silver.

Should I clean my coins before selling them?

No. Cleaning almost always lowers the value of a collectible coin. Bring them in as they are.

Can I sell a whole collection at once?

Yes. Bring the full collection, albums and sets included. Keeping it together means each coin gets looked at, not just the ones on top.

Do I have to sell, or can I borrow against my coins?

You can do either. A pawn loan lets you keep ownership and get the coins back when you repay.

Sell your coins in Huntington

Call 631-735-6880 or stop by 1786 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743. Selling gold jewelry too? Read about how we buy gold on Long Island.

A pile of old coins is shown in this photo